Sunday, March 13, 2011

How to not make a decision



Alice came to a fork in the road. "Which road do I take?" she asked.
"Where do you want to go?" responded the Cheshire cat.
"I don't know," Alice answered.
"Then," said the cat, "it doesn't matter."

~Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland

I've been feeling a bit like Alice lately. I've been in a strange sort of paralysis for a few weeks now - I had a few big things I needed to make decisions on, one to do with my younger son, another to do with my career.

Funnily enough, in the workplace I'm very decisive. But in my personal life I'm quite a prevaricator. And I've been prevaricating about this stuff for a while.

This weekend, I turned a corner. I was at a birthday party and got talking to another parent. She said something - nothing I hadn't thought of before - but it made the issue about my younger son seem suddenly obvious. And Mr T was pleased because it meant I agreed with him.

Having made that one decision, the others seemed to come much more easily. It was as though a blockage had been removed.

I'm not sure the weeks of paralysis were such a bad thing. Maybe they were part of the process? Maybe all the material I needed to consider was fermenting away in my brain the whole time, getting mashed down ready for analysis. Or maybe I just wasn't in the right frame of mind to make big personal decisions 'til this weekend.

During those weeks, I used my reading matter quite consciously as a distraction. When I'd start feeling overwhelmed, I'd pick up my Kindle and within moments, I'd be ring-fenced from my worries. Escapism? Yes.
Not escapism from daily life, but escapism from a state of mind that was stressful. A distraction from a repetitive train of thought I was finding it difficult to reach any kind of conclusion on.

Is romance better escapism/distraction than other forms of literature? For me, yes, I think so. Something about the emotional content being more consuming perhaps. Something perhaps around precisely what it is being engaged, not merely the attention of the brain but emotional energy? I don't know precisely. It's difficult to articulate what it is about reading a romance novel that enables me to almost 'close off' an unproductive/ difficult train of thought and replace it with a new channel for my mental energy.

I don't use romance novels as distraction very often - I usually just read them cos I like them. But this last week or two, I absolutely have.

What about you? Do you ever need to escape, and if so, how do you achieve it? Between the pages of a book? If so, what is your ultimate escape read? I found Anne Stuart's Breathless highly effective...

6 comments:

Jill Sorenson said...

I don't think I read to escape but your post reminded me of something I went through a few months ago. My youngest daughter went to the dentist for the first time and had a bunch of cavities! The dentist said the reason for most cavities is "poor nutrition and neglect" and I wanted to burst into tears. I knew I hadn't done a good enough job (I'd been letting her brush her own teeth without my help, and wasn't paying much attention because my older daughter has never had a cavity). To make a long story short, she had to be anesthetized for dental work and I was devastated. Cried and cried, felt like worst mom in world, etc. etc.

Around this time I read a book by Victoria Dahl--Crazy For You, which was both a catharsis and an escape. The hero is an anxiety-ridden but lovable control freak. Reading his story made me feel better about myself. Even now I feel like crying, thinking about it. That book was comforting and I wanted an escape, but it actually helped me face my problems.

Hope all is well with you and your little ones.

Anonymous said...

In my thinking, decisions about children are always so replete with hope, even having been remade one remains uncertain for at least a decade or two. Good luck.

As for reading romance ficton? Absolutely. Unrepentant escapism.

dick

Kathryn said...

Escape may be too strong a word. Now respite is a word I can support. When I seek respite it is usually in early Jayne Ann Krentz books. But I'm with Jill Sorenson; sometimes "Chance favors the prepared mind".

Tumperkin said...

Oh, Jill, poor you, I feel for you. So very easily done. My youngest is a terrible tooth-brusher - though in his case he blatantly chews the brush and runs around which is just as well, because if he quietly stood there and just brushed badly, I'd probably barely notice given how rushed bedtime always is.

dick/Kathryn - thanks for your comments. I'm always interested in how people relate to the word 'escapism'. Hearkening back to a post I did once about 'seduction' (see link below), 'escapsim' is another of those words that seem to provoke both positive and negative responses.

http://tumperkin.blogspot.com/2010/11/on-ducal-seduction-and-other.html

Anonymous said...

Janet W: I think I'm entering a watershed time for my reading. I used to read oh of course for enjoyment and legal transportation into another dimension and so on and so forth but my latest reading, Separate Beds, by Eliz Buchan, was intensely of the moment and covered serious themes (like the financial meltdown) and I loved it. http://bookloversresource.com/book-lovers-resource/tbr-challenge-2011-separate-beds-by-elizabeth-buchan And now I'm reading the most recent Chelsea Cain, a suspense thriller, another #almostneverreadfor me. I'm not trying to borrow trouble *pausing to touch wood* but I've wrestled with some major changes over the past year or so and as they've started to take shape, I feel embolded to inch ever so slowly out of my comfort zone.

Books are my drug of choice and books that I love (Heyer and Balogh) are my vehicle of escape. It's great to know that books can also accompany one as one ventures out of the cocoon.

Jill, my most heartfelt sympathy ... my mother used to say to me that "our children are hostages to fortune" and oh no I understand that now. I'm so glad you had a book friend to hold your hand and give you some respite. There are no perfect mothers you know. Sadly. So from one non-perfect mum to another, just try to move on. Hugs.

lookingfortheredpill said...

I am a staunch believer of escapism. Or to put it in a rather more apt manner, I have an acute grudge against people who deride escapism as the cowardly way to lead life.

Life holds different meaning/purpose for different people. I have the freedom to choose my own whims and fantasies and let them lead me to the path I wish to take. Of course, as long as my gay abandon for life is not hurting my near and dear ones. And hurting because of their concern for me doesn't count :S
What ever happened to live and let live :S